The Irritable Gut

The Irritable Gut2018-08-02T09:51:54+00:00

IBS vs IBD: What's the Difference?

IBS vs IBD: What’s the Difference?

People can be forgiven if they confuse irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). “IBS” and “IBD” sound the same. Both are very common illnesses that affect the gut. However, about the only features that they have in common are gut symptoms such as abdominal pain and diarrhea, a tendency to affect young people, chronicity, and our ignorance of their ultimate cause. It is unfortunate that the initials for these contrasting conditions are so similar.

To add to the confusion, “IBD” is used to describe two distinct, but different structural diseases: ulcerative colitis and Crohn’s disease. The former affects only the lining of the large intestine or colon, while Crohn’s disease may affect any part and all layers of the gut. For many reasons, which are not relevant to this discussion, these two inflammatory conditions are usually lumped together as IBD.

 

Symptoms and Evidence

The fundamental difference between IBS and IBD is that IBD is structural, and IBS is not. By “structural,” we mean that when we examine the gut by x-ray, endoscopy, surgery, or biopsy we can see structural damage to the gut. In IBD, this damage is caused by an inflammation whose origins are poorly understood, but whose consequences may require hospitalization, heavy-duty medication, nutritional support, and often surgery. In IBS, none of the forgoing is true. Examination of the gut of a person who has IBS will be unrevealing. We know IBS exists because patients have gut symptoms, and there is no other way to detect it.

 

Demographics

Both affect people of all ages but they are particularly prominent in young people. Females are more likely to have IBS, and it affects all races. IBD has no gender preference and is most common in Jewish individuals and those with origins in Northern Europe. IBS appears to be a worldwide disorder, while IBD prefers the planet’s temperate zones. More than half of people who have IBS symptoms seek no medical attention, while few IBD sufferers can avoid it.

 

Inflammation

In IBD, the gut is damaged by the chronic inflammation. This damage is resisted by the body’s defences, resulting in fever and malaise. The disrupted intestines may bleed and anemia (low blood) is common. The inability to eat during attacks, and wasting of energy caused by the inflammation, result in weight loss and malnutrition.

There are no findings on physical examination that are characteristic of IBS. However, the structural damage of IBD may produce striking physical findings such as a mass in the abdomen, an abnormal communication of the gut with the skin (fistula), an anal abscess, or the physical features of weight loss and anemia.

 

Symptoms Outside of the GI Tract

In IBD, inflammation may occur beyond the gut in the skin, joints, and eyes for examples. The resulting dermatitis, arthritis, and iritis (red, sore eye) can be as debilitating as the IBD itself. None of these physical disabilities result from IBS, and having IBS does not predispose one to IBD, nor any other structural condition such as cancer, celiac disease, nor diverticulosis. While neither condition will shorten life expectancy, most of those with IBD will require surgery at some time during their illness.

Sometimes psychological disease is thought to be a part of IBS. Certainly, some patients who seek medical attention may also have psychosocial problems that require attention in their own right. However, there is little evidence that this is true of IBS overall, and psychosocial difficulties are found in some people with IBD as well. While many people with IBS complain of social inconvenience, embarrassment, fear of appearing in public, and work loss, these features are more universal and profound in IBD, as the foregoing comparisons imply. While IBD is described as a structural or “organic” disease, IBS is said to be functional or a disorder of function. None of these terms is entirely satisfactory.

 

IBS vs IBD: Two Very Different Illnesses

It is of vital importance to distinguish these two very different gut conditions. While both are chronic, the overall treatment and prognosis are very different. There are other important considerations. Because so may people have IBS, it is not surprising that some will also acquire IBD. That is, they may occur in the same patient due to chance. It is therefore crucial that the IBS symptoms in these patients not be confused with those due to IBD. The powerful, often expensive, sometimes-toxic drugs employed to treat IBD will not improve IBS symptoms. There are many reported instances where IBD has been “misdiagnosed” as IBS for years until finally the diagnosis is made. A more likely explanation is that IBS was present first (remember it is very common) and the IBD started later.

Finally, both IBD and IBS may be mistaken for other diseases such as appendicitis, diverticulitis, and chronic gut infections. Careful attention to the medical history and a thorough physical examination should avoid any such confusion.

Both IBD and IBS trouble many people. However, because of its propensity to damage the gut and other organs, IBD may produce disfigurement and sometimes-permanent physical disability. While there is no doubt IBS patients can suffer greatly from symptoms, their outlook is better than those who have IBD. A perusal of Table 1 illustrates many important reasons to distinguish the two conditions.

 

Table 1: The Different Characteristics of IBS & IBD

Characteristic

IBS

Irritable Bowel Syndrome
(defined by symptom criteria)

IBD

Inflammatory Bowel Disease
(ulcerative colitis and Crohn’s disease)

Structural Change in Gut No Yes
Prevalence 13-20% 0.7%
Age All All
Gender More common in females About equal
Race All More in Jewish, Less in Blacks
Geography Worldwide Highest in Canada
Seek health care About 30% Virtually all
Fever, Anemia, Rectal bleeding, malnutrition No Yes
Abdominal mass No Sometimes
Complications in Gut, Skin, Joints, Eyes No Yes
Life expectancy Normal Almost normal
Need for Surgery No Often
Physical Disability No Often
Psychological Co-morbidity Sometimes Sometimes
Social Inconvenience Often Frequently

 


W. Grant Thompson, MD,  Emeritus Professor of Medicine
Image Credit: © bigstockphoto.com/Raymond Gregory
First published in the Inside Tract® newsletter issue 126 – July/August 2001
Table updated in 2015